Facebook defends blocking women who call men ‘scum’

Facebook confirms it’s suspending the accounts of women who call men “scum” in the wake of the sexual harassment scandals that have sparked the #MeToo conversation on social media and beyond.

“We understand how important it is for victims of harassment to be able to share their stories and for people to express anger and opinions about harassment,” a spokeswoman for the social networking giant told SiliconBeat Tuesday. In fact, Facebook COO Sheryl Sandberg addressed sexual harassment over the weekend, warning of a backlash against women and urging companies to do better when they’re told about such instances.

But the spokeswoman said Facebook draws “the line when people attack others simply on the basis of their gender.”

So if men call women scum, they’re also supposed to face consequences, per the social networking giant’s community standards.

Get tech news in your inbox weekday mornings. Sign up for the free Good Morning Silicon Valley newsletter.

Similarly, race is a protected class, so racial slurs are theoretically not allowed on Facebook and should also result in a ban.

But according to a website where people are sharing their stories about being suspended by Facebook, the company’s enforcement of its community standards are uneven.

The stories on Facebook Jailed include that of writer and comedian Rae Sanni, who includes a screenshot of someone telling her: “kill yourself, [n-word].”

Sanni wrote on Twitter a couple of weeks ago that she has “reported the dozens of racist and sexist slurs I was called on public posts and messaged privately, and weirdly, none of them went against FB’s terms of service.” However, she said her post in which she called men “scum” in solidarity with a friend — her co-host on the podcast “Misandry with Marcia and Rae,” who was banned by Facebook — was removed by the company.

When Facebook users find objectionable content on the site, they can report it to the company. Those complaints are sent to content reviewers, who number in the thousands and work around the clock all over the world.

(In May, as Facebook was dealing with a rash of violent video content, CEO Mark Zuckerberg said the company would add 3,000 content reviewers. The company’s team of reviewers will number 7,500 by the end of the year, it says.)

In their podcast Monday, Sanni and Marcia Belsky talked about being banned by Facebook.

Sanni said she has been targeted by right-wing trolls on social media. On Facebook, where she had been temporarily banned after a discussion with someone over NFL players’ protests over racism and police brutality, she felt powerless to respond to people being racist and sexist toward her.

“They’re silencing the people being harassed,” Belsky said. She also said she has reported a post that said “women are scum” and it was not removed.

The two also speculated that bans get lifted when the media brings attention to them.

This isn’t the first time Facebook has faced questions about how it determines who gets banned from its service, especially its suspension of black users. It was one of the concerns voiced by the Congressional Black Caucus when its members met with Sandberg in October.

In a letter to the CBC dated Nov, 29, Sandberg wrote: “We continue to explore how we can adopt a more granular approach to hate speech, both in the way we draft our policies and the way we enforce on them.”

Facebook has apologized for removing posts by black activists, including a woman who over the summer posted screenshots of hateful comments she was getting after joking about whether she would survive a trip to Cracker Barrel, a restaurant notorious for having to settle lawsuits accusing it of discriminating against black people.

When ProPublica reported in June about Facebook’s censorship practices, it pointed out that the company let stand a Republican congressman’s call to kill “radicalized” Muslims but removed a Black Lives Matter activist’s statement that “all white people are racist.”

And in another example, Facebook last year temporarily took down the live stream of the aftermath of the police shooting of Philando Castile, a black man who later died, in Minnesota. The company later said it was a glitch.


Photo by Associated Press


Tags: , , , , , , , , , ,


Share this Post

  • singerff

    block judy valente

  • Kool

    I’m happy this story comes to print. Thank you. Happened to me a few times.

  • Thelip95032

    So now Facebook is deciding what is free speech, wonder if the milenials will ever understand how cummunistic FB is.

    • Michelle Abrahmz

      Wonder if you’ll ever learn how to spell correctly?

  • matt10023

    If men routinely suggested women are bad because of their gender, there’d be an understandable outcry. When it’s reversed, women complain.

  • Some Guy

    Sounds like the SJWs have gotten exactly what they’ve wanted. A completely G rated world where no wrong think happens in public except the think police are applying it to them as well. Were they really stupid enough to think FB was just going to apply this to people with certain ideologies? I think we can all agree how stupid the online bullying thing is now. It’s not a real issue. There’s a reason there’s a block button. People need to be taught to have thicker skins so companies won’t feel compelled to implement stupid guidelines. If you kill yourself over online harassment you’re an idiot. Darwinism at work. Just my honest harsh opinion. Idiots kill themselves or hurt others because people were mean to them online.