iPhone
With Apple expected to unveil its tablet computer next Wednesday, my Tech Files column on Monday will be about some of the features I hope the tablet will include.
But I’ve also been thinking a lot about something else that Apple might announce at its special event: iPhone 4.0, the latest version of the operating system that underlies its iPhone and iPod touch gadgets. Apple announced the last two major updates to the iPhone OS at March events, but recent rumors suggest that this update will be unveiled two months early.
The last two updates included significant new features for the iPhone. iPhone 2.0 opened the device to native third-party applications and paved the way for the company’s trend-setting and uber-successful App Store. iPhone 3.0 added long-awaited features, such as copy and paste, multi-media messaging and stereo Bluetooth. I’m hopeful that iPhone 4.0 will be just as significant a release.
Here are some of the things I’d like to see in it:Multi-tasking. This is perhaps the iPhone’s biggest short-coming right now compared with Android phones or other smartphone devices. Unlike those devices, you generally can’t run more than one application at once. (There are a few exceptions, such as pulling up a Web page while you are on the phone, or playing music from the iPod program while doing other tasks.) Instead, in order to pull up another program, you typically have to close down another by pressing the home button.
That’s a pain if you want to switch back and forth between two programs repeatedly. And it also means that you can’t multi-task. On my computer, for instance, I often will check my e-mail while I’m waiting for a Web page to load. You can’t do that on the iPhone.
Most annoyingly, it means that you can’t use any of the great audio programs now available for the iPhone — such as WunderRadio or Pandora — while you are doing anything else, like checking your mail or using a turn-by-turn navigation program. It also would be nice to allow some of the location-based programs — like the yet-to-be-available as a native app Google Latitude — to run in the background while you did other things.
Apple’s excuse in the past for not allowing multi-tasking has been that it would run down the battery too easily. But the Palm Pre and the new Android devices, which run on similar hardware as the iPhone, get similar battery life as Apple’s gadget, despite allow multi-tasking.
Apple has made a stab in the direction of multi-tasking by allowing programs to receive background notifications, even when they aren’t running. But this is a half-solution at best, and doesn’t really address the issue. You can’t listen to Pandora via a background notification.
Unobtrusive notifications. Speaking of notifications, I’d like Apple to take a page from Palm and Google and make them less obtrusive.
On the iPhone, notifications for things such as a new text message or a low battery come in the form of a box that overlays whatever you are looking at at the time. You can dismiss the message, but you have to deal with it in some way before you can go back to what you were doing before. And if you choose to act on the message, the program you were previously working in will be closed.
In contrast, on both the webOS and Android phones, if you get a text message or some other notice, the device alerts you with an icon at the edge of the screen. You can deal with the alert when you want to by clicking on the icon (or pull down the notice bin in Android); you don’t have to stop what you are doing at the time.
In my book, the webOS and Android solutions to notifications are much more elegant and user-friendly than the iPhone’s.
Flash support. I know. Steve Jobs has said that Flash in its current state isn’t a good fit for smartphones. The full PC version of Flash is too system intensive for the devices. And Flash Lite, which the company is pushing for mobile devices, isn’t capable enough.
But that situation looks like it’s about to change. Palm has already announced that the new Pre will support Flash later this year — and so too will Android devices. If the iPhone doesn’t, it risks being left behind.
Because here’s the thing. At least right now — and for the foreseeable future — Flash is a key component of the Web experience. There’s just a lot of content, from videos to games that you can’t view without it.
Apple has tried to work around this by pushing its QuickTime media standard, HTML 5, which is an alternate means of delivering Web content, and by encouraging companies to develop native apps for the iPhone. To some degree that’s helped, but there’s still a lot of content out there on the Web that’s currently inaccessible from the iPhone.
Widgets. This is one of the cool features of Android. Widgets are small programs that are viewable from the phone’s home screen that are always running. They can include such things as weather information, stock quotes or sports scores. But they can do a lot more.
One of my favorite widgets for Android is one that allows you to toggle off and on its various antennas, such as Bluetooth or WiFi, and its syncing services, such as that with Microsoft Exchange. In order to do something similar on the iPhone, you’d have to pull up the Setting programs and got deep within several of its menus. In other words, it’s a lot easier with a widget.
As I mentioned in my review of the Motorola Cliq, Motorola has built its Motoblur service around widgets that deliver updates from users social networks and that display the latest messages in users’ universal inbox. It would be cool to have similar widgets for the iPhone.
Social networking integration. I love the Facebook application for the iPhone. But webOS and Android have taken Facebook (and social networking access in general) to the next level for smartphones. On those phones, your address book not only synchronizes your contacts with those stored Microsoft Exchange mail servers, but also with Facebook and other social networks.
So the address book entry for John Doe might include not only a phone number stored on Exchange, but an e-mail address listed on Facebook, a picture stored on LinkedIn and John’s Twitter address. Motoblur goes even beyond this, allowing users to see a contact’s latest Twitter posts and Facebook updates directly from their address book entry on the phone.
I’d like to see something similar on the iPhone. The latest Facebook app for the device has started to add this feature, but that’s only one social network. I’d like to see much broader support for other networks and Web sites.
Free turn-by-turn navigation. There are now loads of GPS navigation programs available for the iPhone. But they all cost money — sometimes significant chunks of it.
Meanwhile, the trend in turn-by-turn navigation seems to be moving in the other direction. The latest version of Android includes Google’s free turn-by-turn nav service. And Nokia announced today that it would make available a free turn-by-turn nav service for its smartphones, starting with devices like the N97 and the E72. I’d like to see Apple do something similar — or update the Google Maps app to include Google’s nav service.
37 comments
Olive
I REALLY hope the iPhone never gets ‘real multitasking’.
It will just encourage “dead batteries” and “slower devices” and “virus running the background”.
The iphone can *ALREADY* communicate with users… from apps that are NOT even running.
“Push notification” is MUCH better than “multitasking”.
“Multitasking” is so 1985ish.
Jan 21, 2010
Troy Wolverton
Really, Olive? You really don’t want multi-tasking? You never run more than one program on your computer at once? You don’t want the option to do more than one thing at a time on your phone?
As mentioned above, the Android and webOS operating systems have shown that you can have multi-tasking on a device comparable to the iPhone without taking too much of a hit to performance or battery life.
Push notifications were a fine half-step, but they don’t solve the issue. Push notifications don’t allow me to check my e-mail while I’m downloading updates to my iPhone programs, for instance. And they don’t allow me to listen to Pandora while I’m surfing the Web. They also don’t allow me to check my e-mail while I’m loading a Web page. Or any number of other things that I can do easily on my computer — or for that matter, on a Palm Pre or an Android phone.
I have to second the comment below: I wonder if/when you’ll feel the same about multi-tasking when Apple enables it on the iPhone. And multi-tasking is not “1985-ish;” it’s an expected feature on all modern computer operating systems.
Jan 22, 2010
Olive
> notifications for things such as a new text message
> in the form of a box that overlays whatever you are looking
> at at the time.
Huh? Every iphone can choose between getting a:
Pop-up message.
A small icon ‘badge’ counter.
A sound.
Any combination of the above…. including “none”.
Jan 21, 2010
Troy Wolverton
I’ve had my iPhone for well over a year and am very familiar with how it works. As far as I know, there is no option to just get a badge or a sound in place of the message that says you only have 20 percent of your battery life left, or the one that says that you just got a text message or the one that says you just missed a call. Those options with push notifications are only available, as I understand things, with third-party applications.
Don’t get me wrong. I like the idea of push notifications and think there’s a place for them. But there are better ways to implement them than the way Apple has done. webOS and Android show two of those ways.
The problem with the notices on the iPhone is that they are obtrusive, indistinct or potentially hidden. The pop-up message is obviously obtrusive — you have to deal with it either by dismissing or acting on it before you can return to what you were doing.
The sound is indistinct — it could mean any number of things, such as a new e-mail message or a new message from any of a number of programs.
And the badges are potentially hidden. Particularly for programs that are buried deep within your program list, you could get a push notification without ever knowing that you got one.
Jan 22, 2010
Justme
There we go again, another iPhone fan wanting what Android offers for any of its devices.
Just buy an Android with an IPhone look, or install Android on your iPhone and you can stop wishing for all that that Android has had now for some time.
Jan 21, 2010
Troy Wolverton
Thanks, but no, on the “just buy an Android” suggestion, Justme.
First off, I’m still in my contract with AT&T and don’t particularly want to pay for having to cancel it early.
Second, as good as Android’s gotten over the last 18 months — and it’s gotten a lot better since the G1 launched — in many respects, it’s still not as easy to use as the iPhone. In general, the iPhone’s just a lot more intuitive. And the UI is much more consistent across applications. That’s just not the case yet with Android.
Third, the apps just aren’t there yet for Android. I know, I know the 100,000 app figure in the iPhone App Store is inflated by all the duplicates and downright stupid programs. But that said, the games are way better on the iPhone and you just can’t find programs that are as sophisticated or storage intensive on Android as you can on the iPhone.
Jan 23, 2010
cak
Please, no flash ever. Flash is bad enough on the web, do not trust Adobe to write a decent application, after Arcobat (what is it, >50 meg now), Flash, PS… No thanks.
Jan 21, 2010
teab
I agree with Olive. The iPhone can already notify you of a push notification via pop-up message, badge, or sound, or combination. You just haven’t played enough with your phone settings. Shame, shame, shame.
Jan 21, 2010
art
I don’t understand people with an aversion to advancement. The guy has asked for a few cool features he would like to see; big deal. I have a palm pre and I love the phone but that doesn’t make it perfect. I would love to see the phone be faster more like the iphone, I would like to be able to shoot video like the iphone but that does not mean I want an iphone. I want the best feature from everyone phone on my phone. I think you all must have the last name of dumbass.
Jan 21, 2010
David
Have to agree.. say no to multitasking. Had it on Windows Mobile forever and it is a total disaster.
Jan 22, 2010
awaybbl
What I’d like, in addition to multi-tasking, is access to the file system. It’d be neat if I could “see” the files on my device, and be able to use them from any app that can read the format. Also it’d be nice to make “folders” on the home screen to help me organize the home page a little better.
Jan 22, 2010
Mark
““Multitasking” is so 1985ish.”…um, and what would be the “only allowed to run
one app at a time” model, so 2010ish? Please, this is the largest shortcoming
of the iPhone, which is essentially a small mobile computer. When was the
last time you bought a computer that let you only run one app?
Jan 22, 2010
dude
The auth wasn’t talking about Push notifications. Read it again…he said text messages and low battery notifications
Jan 22, 2010
Eric
I like to see voice guided operation on iPhone besides the voice activation of phone calls, it’ll be convenient to use voice to open your app, like Pandora..
Jan 22, 2010
Ryan
i want the iphone but my mum and dad will not get me it but someway i will get it haha LLLLLLOOOOOOOOOOLLLLLLLLLLLL =D
Jan 22, 2010
tsc
It is almost certain that iPhone OS 4.0 will be announced next week. And multi-tasking will be one of the new features. This is because the tablet computer is a much more powerful device. There is no reason Apple will not allow multi-tasking on it.
My previous cellphone is a Sony Ericcson which includes a pedometer function. I use it very often. With the iPhone 3GS I no longer can do it. It is simply because the OS does not multi-task.
Jan 22, 2010
Josh
One thing i wish apple would do, and it’s a small thing, is to allow a user to mark multiple email messages as read/unread. i have so many emails, most of which i check on my computer, and when i do check it on my phone, it’s annoying to see that the same email is shown as “not read”.
Jan 22, 2010
Justin
I agree screw flash and multitasking I have an iPod that multitasks everything and the phone when you have speaker or the supplied headphones with mic and controls
just allow me to make folders for organization having a mess off 11 screens then extra unseeable ones is ridiculous and my main gripe about the 3g and 3gs that and I would like a static homepage and like I said home screens organization
Jan 22, 2010
bob
I almost choked when I read the comment about:
> “I REALLY hope the iPhone never gets ‘real multitasking’.
>> It will just encourage “dead batteries” and “slower devices” and “virus >> running the background”.
>> “Multitasking” is so 1985ish.
Are you serious? That’s like saying there should be a throttle on how many phone calls you can make per day because, you know, making alot of phone calls only encourages dead batteries. And viruses running in the background are different than viruses running in the foreground because …?
If mutitasking is so 1985-ish then single tasking OSs are so 1950-ish. Can you imagine a computer OS company trying to convince people that multitasking is bad for them?
It’s amazing the apple kool-aide people swallow. If apple doesn’t have a feature then it is obviously not important. I wonder what the reaction will be if and when apple implements true multitasking.
Jan 22, 2010
Dixie
Cell phone wars will rage forever. You will always have die-hards. Apple fans who love Apple because it’s Apple. I don’t disagree that Apple has a solid reputation and their products are mostly top-notch. Personally, I have an iPhone, and see no reason for Apple to do anything to their precious baby simply because PEOPLE WILL BUY IT NO MATTER WHAT. Apple has some amazing features that people love and they will forgo other features because they don’t care about them or don’t understand them. Sure, it’d be great if Apple took a hint from the overabundance of Android phones coming out and tweak their OS a little. But if there’s a feature you can’t live without, buy a different phone. I’m currently browsing because there are things I would like my iPhone to do but it can’t, and I don’t see much change for the OS in the future. You have to make the decision between whether you buy a product for the label or the features. I’m not saying one is right or wrong, but don’t buy an iPhone because you love Apple and then complain because they won’t make advancements. Because, quite frankly, they don’t have to. You don’t have to compete when you own over 50% of the market…
Jan 22, 2010
Josh
Download the Backgrounder app fool! Enables Backgrounding! Poorly researched article, epic fail!
Jan 22, 2010
Jim
@JOSH – get/use IMAP instead of POP and that should take care of it
Jan 22, 2010
Pete Shaw
Troy,
Don’t worry, Jobs is way ahead of you on these and other goodies. I expect
iPhone 4.0 and 4G (LTE-VZ) to “Terminate” the DROIDs like Arnold
Schwarzenegger!
BTW, some “dream features” are just not reasonable on a
cell phone, so don’t expect to see a Cray Supercomputer iPhone.
P3T3
Jan 22, 2010
patrik
What I like to do is set the bar supernaturally high, then criticize the product for not meeting those expectations.
For example, the iPhone should have a holographic interface, like in “Avatar.” It doesn’t, therefore it sucks and Apple doesn’t know what it’s doing.
I will not waste my money on an iPhone because it lacks holographic features as well as the ability to clean my sink.
Jan 22, 2010
Magnus
One of my friend just purchased a Nexus One 3 days ago. It’s a beautiful phone indeed. He purchased it, however, for the sake of it’s multi-tasking ability. The verdict is in. The phone has crashed several times when he would open 3 apps all at once. No matter which apps he opens, the phone either just slow down and then eventually meets it’s temporary sudden-death. We’re both convinced that the Nexus One just doesn’t have enough “memory” capacity to handle multiple apps all at once without getting into too much trouble with system overload.
I have the same problem with my iPhone 3GS 32GB. My iPhone always crash whenever I use “spotlight” to search for a particular app. This only happens, however, when I install more than 500 apps. For some reason the search function just can’t handle this many apps. I’ve restored at least 6x and have taken my iPhone to the Genius Bar 3x. They’ve been unable to figure out the problem. I have accumulated 700+ apps (most are for reviewing purposes) and are only able to install less than 500 apps. This is the limit. There’s been a thread @ APPLE support discussing this problem. I hope they’ve addressed this issue if indeed one of the 4.0 upgrade includes additional “screens” to accommodate more than 180 apps.
I’m apprehensive with the idea of having “multi-tasking” with my iPhone. If my iPhone can’t handle more than 500+ apps, how in the world can it handle mutitple apps going all at once?
I’m definitely for “advancements.” However, if it advancements compromise system operation efficiency, then I say “No Thanks.” I will wait for the next generation iPhone that can truly handle multi-tasking without worrying about system overload, frequent crashing, rebooting, restoring, etc. Of course, if one is given an option to system preferences i.e. able to activate/de-activate multi-tasking then by all means go for it. I know for sure that I will de-activate multi-tasking if it becomes a headache.
For the record, I can do without “Flash.” I have “Flash” with my Mac and it’s a freakin nightmare. Adobe hasn’t perfected it, yet. I don’t want it on my iPhone. If it slows down (and often freezes) my MacBookPro, then I certainly can guarantee that it will wreak havoc to my iPhone.
Jan 22, 2010
drewshaver
For those wary of multi tasking, I have a moto droid, I have never had a problem with multi tasking. Bad experiences with the N1 are just that, with the N1. All androids do not operate like this. Honestly, sounds like there is smothenig seriously wrong with his hardware, he should return it.
I’ve been using moto droid since november, multi tasking is great, most important is on long drives so i can pandora + driving directions. Multi tasking will not wreck your phone.
Jan 23, 2010
Raf
@Magnus. You’re friend has a shotty Nexus 1. My Nexus 1 is running … hold on and let me count…8 apps at the same time.. they are Facebook, Myspace, Google Maps, Gmail, web, voice search, New and weather widget, Google Voice and my phone is still blazingly fast and I haven’t once gotten a Force close notification or my “phone crashed” which Android doesnt do, FYI. i phone is an amazing device but Android is also an amazing OS.
Jan 23, 2010
John
Here’s a small thing, but it’s both for iPhone and the Mac itself. When you delete a message from the inbox on a pop account, delete it from the server as well. Drives me crazy, especially on the iPhone because it will constantly re-download emails you have deleted previously if you don’t otherwise go in and delete them off the server! Fortunately at least the Mac doesn’t do that trick!
Jan 23, 2010
Crk
This sort of amuses me, because the iPhone Jailbreak users already have
a lot of this stuff…
Jan 23, 2010
Mel
I like making phone calls with my phone.
Jan 25, 2010
jaybeecham
This thread has been amusing… I don’t have my references right, but I have to lean with the user who said if you want an iPhone, for whatever reason, buy one, and then push for the features you want. Ultimately, after pleasing Steve Jobs, the Apple programmers First Priority is to answer to the customers. My features are:
A folder organization system for attachments or general files.
Multi-tasking, but closing out an app to go to another is a bore.
Also like to see more integrated features, specifically:
— Block problem callers from the call history screen.
–Create contact entry from Maps/Nav screen.
–Affordable voice driven GPS/Nav system
–Workining Google 411 Application
–Etc…
Just little things like that. I bought the iPhone because the UI design set the bar for everyone else, just like the iPod, just like the iMac. Icing on the cake that the OS system crashes once for every hundred times my pc based os’s crash.
Have a great day!
~jhb
Jay Beecham
208-585-1208
Jan 25, 2010
Champ Kind
Just jailbreak using blackra1n and you can have access to the majority of these features now. I was very hesitant to do this at first, but after extensive research, and subsequently using a jailbroken device for the last 3 months, I can highly recommend it to anyone who is in the least bit savvy with computer technology. iPhone is pretty cool as is, but it is an absolute beast once it has been let out of jail.
Jan 29, 2010
Daves
What about themes?? or backgrounds for your home screen? its the only reason i jailbroke, but would return to being “unjailbroken” if apple allowed me to customize my phone more!
Feb 3, 2010
Daves
oh and Mel, you are too funny!
Feb 3, 2010
Bill McMinn
WiFi tethering would be nice
Feb 8, 2010
iphone apps
What an advantage to have a multi-function features of my Here are some of of my iPhone mobile. Very impressive of having this.
Feb 22, 2010
Paige Mustafa
I printed a lot of iPhone 4.0? Here’s what I’d like to see | SiliconBeat out thanks my friend
Mar 8, 2010