SiliconBeat

The people and companies driving the innovation of Silicon Valley

Carl Icahn’s view of corporate America: Theater of the Absurd

Corporate raider, or corporate savior Carl Icahn has started his own blog, The Icahn Report. A sampling of titles since it rolled out last week: “Absurdity of Corporate Board Elections,” “Absurdity of the Staggered Board,” and “Absurdity of the Poison Pill.” Yesterday’s post was titled “Corporate Democracy is a Myth.”

You’d think Carl might have some thoughts on Yahoo, which failed to heed Icahn’s advice on reigniting Microsoft’s desire, or Biogen Idec, whose shareholders just rejected Icahn’s candidates for that company’s board today, but no.

There is much that is quotable on Icahn’s blog, but we pass along this “slightly facetious”metaphor from his post Monday titled “About CEOs–Anti-Darwinian Metaphor–Survival of the
Unfittest” about the way CEOs become CEOs in America:

“If you remember if you were in college the fraternity president was always there for you. When you had nothing to do or when you were a little depressed. Feeling down. You go to the club and the fraternity president would always be there. You wondered when he had time to study which he probably didn’t do very much of in school. He was there to sympathize with you if your girlfriend didn’t show up or didn’t call you back and you obviously sort of liked the guy because the fraternity president was usually a likeable guy.

“When the elections came up you would always vote for him. He had a couple qualities - the
fraternity president. Politically, he was a survivor and he never made many waves. He did not
promote controversy. Therefore when he went out into corporate America he was able to move up the ladder fairly quickly. Remember he survived, he didn’t make waves, and he wasn’t a threat. He kept moving up and up.

“Eventually he becomes the assistant to the CEO. The CEO had the same qualities. He’s a
survivor. He’d never employ anyone underneath him who might be a threat. The boards like these guys… this type of CEO. The boards generally don’t own any stock (another problem with oursystem). The boards don’t really care to hold CEOs accountable. Remember it’s a symbiotic relationship. These guys pay the boards very well — they give the boards perks. The boards don’t care to hold them accountable because that might endanger the perks they love so much.

“When the CEO retires the assistant becomes the CEO. And remember what I told you. He’s a
survivor. He would never have anyone underneath him as his assistant that’s brighter than he is because that might constitute a threat. So therefore, with many exceptions, we have CEOs becoming dumber and dumber and dumber. We can all see where this is going. It would almost be funny if it wasn’t such a threat to our ability to compete and to our economy in general.”

Share/Save/Bookmark

3 Responses to “Carl Icahn’s view of corporate America: Theater of the Absurd”

  1. I must say that Mr. Icahn does hit the nail on the head in several comments here.

    Although I do not agree with the Yahoo buyout by Microsoft due to the nature of companies these days struggling to find ways to capture market leadership.

    Innovation through acquisition creates significant in balance for many reasons but the core is synergy. The same synergy that the CEO climbs to the top with.

    If the U.S. economy is to regain its economic strength before lost, we do need to consider what real value is.

    I personally believe a major fix would be to completely eliminate the ideal of public funding feeding a company with revenue. Thats right. No more Dow Jones, Nasdaq, NYSE! Companies would only be able to acquire what they produce.

    No smoke and mirrors…

    What would Mr. Icahn do in this situation?

Trackbacks & Pingbacks

  1. Icahn joins blogosphere, gets blank stares | IR Web Report:

    [...] Blogging journalist Jack Davis of the San Jose Mercury News quotes a passage from one of Icahn’s posts: Carl Icahn’s view of corporate America: Theater of the Absurd [...]

    --June 20, 2008 @ 12:05 am
  2. theceodaily.com» Morning Update » June 20, 2008:

    [...] - TheDeal.com Memo to blogger Icahn: Give power to the people, not your lawyers - Chicago Tribune Carl Icahn’s view of corporate America: Theater of the Absurd - San Jose Mercury News Icahn launches blog, highlights corporate ‘absurdities’ - IDG [...]

    --June 20, 2008 @ 4:55 am

Leave a Reply